top of page

#manifestorakyat2021

3l: Agriculture


Preamble

There are two categories of agriculture production in Malaysia: commodity and

food. The former falls under the Ministry of Plantation Industries and

Commodities (MPIC); the latter, the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industry

(MAFI). Commodity production is largely operated by large companies—for

example, only 40% of oil palm is cultivated by small farmers. On the other hand,

approximately 90% of producers in the food sector are smallholder farmers.

Despite improvements in food production, Malaysia continues to be a net

importer of food, as 100% self-sufficiency is still impossible due to poor policies

and implementation. Some of the imports are for the local industry to add value

and export later. The main food imports are temperate fruits and vegetables,

wheat, sugar, salt, beef and mutton.

Locally, the demand and need for agricultural produce are growing as

consumption patterns change, especially among the urban population. When the

COVID-19 pandemic broke out, local food production and distribution were

disrupted due to the limited supply of raw materials and inputs, shortages in

labour and market access, hindrances in global supply chains and exports, as well

as an overall slowdown in agriculture services due to lockdowns and transport

restrictions. In 2020, we imported food products worth RM55.5 billion compared

with exports worth RM33.8 billion. This resulted in an increased trade deficit in

food products amounting to RM21.7 billion, a difference of 24.9% from the

previous year.

I. Food Security & Sovereignty

Many reports conclude that the root causes of the country’s low agricultural

backwardness stems from the lack of use of modern technology and

unproductive smallholder farmers due to uneconomical farm size. Rarely

discussed are the major problems of farmers, such as subsidy leakages largely

enjoyed by supplier companies and contractors (non-farmers), market

exploitation of input and yield prices, oppressive corporate monopolies, debt

traps, and entry of low-quality foreign products that are cheap, unregulated and

exploit stakeholders. Our failure to identify real problems in the field will only

exacerbate the situation when new technologies and control systems are

introduced.

1. Give farmers freedom over seeds, agricultural inputs and market

choices.

i. Loosen overly formal controls in our agricultural ecosystem.

ii. Repeal laws governing the freedom of farmers, such as the Seed Quality

Act and the Amendment to the Protection of New Plant Varieties Act

2004.

iii. Break up the monopoly of supply of agricultural inputs and the market

of agricultural products, whether by agencies or the private sector.

(NurFitri Amir Muhammad, Forum Kedaulatan Makanan Malaysia, Proposal 3L-1)

2. Do not sign any free trade agreements (FTAs).

FTAs will remove import controls on agricultural products, leading to the

flooding of cheap and low-quality products from supplier countries, which will

affect the local market.

(NurFitri Amir Muhammad, Forum Kedaulatan Makanan Malaysia, Proposal 3L-1)

3. Decentralise the agricultural ecosystem—i.e. create a new ecosystem

based on local nature.

Decentralisation will reduce costs and the risk of logistical failure, especially in

the event of a crisis.

(NurFitri Amir Muhammad, Forum Kedaulatan Makanan Malaysia, Proposal 3L-1)

4. Empower the Federal Agricultural Marketing Authority (FAMA) to buy

farmers’ products through cold storage systems in each locality.

Through this system, FAMA can also help local farmers sell their produce at

affordable prices for both the local and export markets.

(Ku Nurasyiqin Ku Amir, activist/Ph.D. student, Proposal 3L-2)

5. Implement modest economies of scale through the establishment of

local cooperatives or companies that are confined to the area.

(Bawani K.S., Jaringan MARHAEN, Proposal 3L-3; NurFitri Amir Muhammad, Forum Kedaulatan Makanan Malaysia, Proposal 3L-1)

6. Limit farm areas.

Prevent large-scale estate farming which leads to monopoly and more harm to

the environment and farmers’ welfare.

(Bawani K.S., Jaringan MARHAEN, Proposal 3L-3)

7. Change the current subsidy system to direct assistance to farmers.

Rather than benefiting farmers, the current subsidy system is exploited by

vendors. Direct assistance would be better, such as coupon systems or metric

cards to buy agricultural inputs.

(NurFitri Amir Muhammad, Forum Kedaulatan Makanan Malaysia, Proposal 3L-1)

8. Help small and medium agricultural entrepreneurs to compete at a

higher level without involving established corporate companies.

Government assistance in the form of finance or support for established

corporations will only help them expand their monopoly, to the detriment of

smallholder farmers and consumers in the long run.

(Bawani K.S., Jaringan MARHAEN, Proposal 3L-3)

II. Farmers’ Rights

Smallholder farmers are faced with greater risks of falling into poverty when their

income is unstable, which in turn affects dimensions of well-being such as health

and food security. Environmental changes such as weather uncertainties and

disease attacks, the COVID-19 pandemic and rising costs of living have created

greater precarity for farmers, making their work all the more challenging.

Although the National Agro-Food Policy aims to increase production every year,

this will be difficult to achieve if the rights of farmers are not upheld.

9. Upgrade the farmers’ rights component as part of the MAFI policy.

(Ku Nurasyiqin Ku Amir, activist/Ph.D. student, Proposal 3L-2)

Smallholder farmers need several support systems such as social safety nets that

will guarantee their income during periods of bad weather or disease attacks.

They also need assistance from extension officers, who may offer advice and

guidance on improving agricultural practices in order to get better yields or

income. At the same time, there should be an assessment of intergenerational

poverty in peasant families. The direct impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on

the lives of these farmers also needs to be taken into account, especially with

regard to nutrition, education and mental health. Collectively, smallholder

farmers need to understand their rights and be allowed to participate in the

decision-making process at government level.


III: Access to Land

Land is the lifeblood of agriculture. Agriculture is the nation’s backbone, as it

provides food and generates job opportunities, particularly in the rural areas, and

serves as a foundation for the development of the country. The government

should therefore exercise strong political will in providing farmland to

smallholder farmers and ensuring land security for them. The real value and

conditions of land for agriculture should be maintained and preserved, and

priority should be given to smallholders and farmers before a piece of land is

parcelled out to a third party for development.

10. Maintain agricultural areas for food cultivation.

(Vijayagandi Ramasamy, Gabungan Penternak/Jaringan MARHAEN, Proposal 3L-4;

Bawani K.S., Jaringan MARHAEN, Proposal 3L-3; Tan Tean Chee, Persatuan Pertanian

Moden Chemor, Proposal 3L-5)

Only about 10% of available land area designated for agricultural purposes is

used to grow vegetables and fruits. This is largely disproportionate, compared

with the amount of land (over 80%) that is used for oil palm, rubber and other

commodities. If it is absolutely necessary to redevelop land that was previously

secured for agricultural purposes, the government must ensure that the tenant

smallholder farmers and farm animal breeders are duly compensated with a

suitable area of farmland before being evicted, to allow them to carry on with

their agricultural activities.

11. Give smallholder farmers a lease of 20 years.

(John Ku, Activist, Proposal 3L-6; Tan Tean Chee, Persatuan Pertanian Moden Chemor,

Proposal 3L-5)

With enough time, farmers will have confidence that their investment in

developing the land will pay off. Leases on agricultural land should come

attached with the condition that the land can only be used to supply foods.

12. Modify state government standard operating procedures related to land

disposal (alienation of land) to reflect the approach of farmers’ rights to

access to land.

(Vijayagandi Ramasamy, Gabungan Penternak/Jaringan MARHAEN, Proposal 3L-4;)
(Bawani K.S., Jaringan MARHAEN, Proposal 3L-3)

Improve state land regulations by creating a committee to monitor the handling

of government-leased land used by small farmers. Land that is found to have

been changed for non-agricultural related purposes should be reclaimed and

given to other farmers.


Concluding Remarks

The potential value of the agricultural sector should not be measured purely in

terms of business and commodities; it should also be calculated in terms of its

contributions to food security, improving livelihoods in rural areas, farmers'

welfare, and its potential to generate revenue and release resources into other

strategic sectors to propel the nation’s socioeconomic development. The

government needs to acknowledge that this sector will not be able to survive

without implementing important land reforms that serve to regulate competing

land use issues arising from land development, and curb the unscrupulous actions

of certain land developers, especially those from the housing and manufacturing

sectors, who have placed tremendous pressure on the smallholder farming

community. Without food security, the future of the country will not be

guaranteed.

Please fill in all the fields
Sorry You have alreadry submitted your data
Please fill in all the fields
download.jpg

justinleong

For a better and fairer electoral system and to eliminate cronyism, corruption and

Index
First Name
Last Name
Organisation
Submission Date
1
Chee Han
Lim
Agora Society
17/10/2022
1
Swee Lin
Loh
Individual
28/09/2022
2
Laura Sui San
Kho
Mental Health Association of Sarawak (MHAS)
28/06/2022
1
Laura Sui San
Kho
Mental Health Association of Sarawak (MHAS)
28/06/2022
1
Laura Sui San
Kho
Mental Health Association of Sarawak (MHAS)
28/06/2022
1
Laura Sui San
Kho
Mental Health Association of Sarawak (MHAS)
28/06/2022
1
Laura Sui San
Kho
Mental Health Association of Sarawak (MHAS)
28/06/2022
1
Mohd Asraf Sharafi
Mohd Azhar
Individual
25/06/2022
1
Chee Han
Lim
CSO Health Cluster / People's Health Forum
14/06/2022

Endorse the 
Manifesto Rakyat!

Endorsements of the Peoples' Proposals

Sorry You have alreadry submitted your data
Please fill all the fields
Your data was submitted
Index
First Name
Last Name
Organisation
Submission Date
73
YI HUI
LIM
Agora Society Malaysia
07/08/2023
72
iudabiuf
idiubiuafn
kjdbawnk
03/07/2023
71
AMDAN @SABAN
TUMPONG
P.184 LIBARAN
11/11/2022
70
Muhammad Danial
Abdul Majeed
Parti MUDA Pulau Pinang
10/11/2022
69
maimuna
merican
individual
04/11/2022
68
Joshua
P
Keep Green Movement
04/11/2022
67
Kennedy
Michael
Individual
27/10/2022
66
MOHD YAZID
ABDULLAH
INDIVIDU
26/10/2022
63
Pauline
Yong
Individual
20/10/2022
63
Pauline
Yong
Individual
20/10/2022
63
Pauline
Yong
Individual
20/10/2022
62
Nancy
yee
Individual
11/10/2022
61
Nazif
Nani
Individual
11/10/2022
60
Cherlanne
Patrick
Individual
27/09/2022
59
Anusha
Arumugam
Individual
11/09/2022
58
kavein
thran
individual
18/08/2022
57
AZMAN
MOHD RADZI
INDIVIDUAL
19/07/2022
56
ANDREW
PANG
Always for People
18/07/2022
55
Iskandar
Putra
P104 Subang
13/07/2022
54
TK
KOH
SABM
13/07/2022
53
Law
Wogt Min
Individual
09/07/2022
52
SV
Singam
Individual
08/07/2022
51
Alex
Abraham
Individual
07/07/2022
50
Farida
Ibrahim
Saya Anak Bangsa Malaysai
07/07/2022
49
Chithra
Adiyodi
Individual
06/07/2022
48
Kean Seng
Goh
LLG CULTURAL DEVELOPMENT CENTRE
28/06/2022
47
Crietel Eviany
Philip
NA
26/06/2022
46
Subatra
Jayaraj
Individual
25/06/2022
45
Johleen
Koh
Individual
24/06/2022
44
Anwar
Fazal
Individual
22/06/2022
43
mah hui
lim
Individual
22/06/2022
42
ISMAIL
LUMUT
ICON
20/06/2022
41
Wathshlah
Naidu
Centre for Independent Journalism (CIJ)
20/06/2022
40
Dom
Wong
Say No To PJD Link
15/06/2022
39
Suguna
Papachan
Individual
14/06/2022
38
Danesh
Prakash Chacko
TINDAK MALAYSIA
14/06/2022
37
Harmit
Singh
Gerakan Belia Sepunjabi Malaysia
07/06/2022
36
Dennis
Francis
Individual
28/05/2022
35
Leon
Rethual
Individual
28/05/2022
34
Rhea
Martin
Individual
27/05/2022
33
Janette
Matujal
Individual
27/05/2022
32
Faizal
Masri
Individual
27/05/2022
31
Bill
Jugah
Sadia-Rajang/Independent Council Of Natives
27/05/2022
30
Chee Han
Lim
Manifesto Rakyat
27/05/2022
29
Zahid
Alom
Penang Stop Human Trafficking Campaign
27/05/2022
28
Alwi
Muda
Parti Amanah Negara
27/05/2022
27
Xiao Hui
Sem
Individual
27/05/2022
26
Beverly
Joeman
CSO Platform for Reform
27/05/2022
25
Jayanath
Appudurai
Saya Anak Bangsa Malaysia {SABM}
27/05/2022
24
Chee Keong
Chow
Individual
27/05/2022
23
Alice
Tan
Health Equity Initiatives
27/05/2022
22
Calvin Ohsey
Ak Ah Sen
individual
27/05/2022
21
you ping
goh
cdcas
27/05/2022
20
William
Liam
Terabai Kenyalang Heritage Association of Sarawak
27/05/2022
19
Nurizzati
Hamdan
Individual
27/05/2022
18
Sivashankar
Krishnapillai
Individual
27/05/2022
17
Seok Ping
Yu
Individual
27/05/2022
16
Sujatra
Jayaraj
Individual
27/05/2022
15
Remy
Majangkim
BAKAS MC
27/05/2022
14
David
Individual
27/05/2022
13
IRENE
XAVIER
Persatuan Sahabat Wanita Selangor
27/05/2022
12
Haris
Ibrahim
I am the 3rd Force
27/05/2022
11
Michelle R
Usman
Sabah Human Rights Centre
27/05/2022
10
Chan
Yin Hoong
Individual
27/05/2022
9
PH
Wong
Childline Foundation
27/05/2022
8
Sylvester
Gerunsen Jon
Kelab Dayak Pila Sibu (KDPS)
27/05/2022
7
Stanley
Yong
Gabungan Bertindak Malaysia
27/05/2022
6
Jimmy
Berukang
Individual
27/05/2022
5
Yock Lin
Ho
Monsoon Malaysia
27/05/2022
4
ronald
quay
individual
27/05/2022
3
Shanti
Somasundram
Individual
27/05/2022
2
Chia
Yong Tai
Monsoons Malaysia
27/05/2022
1
Mohammad Yunus
Salehi
HEI
27/05/2022

Thank you for your support!

To learn more, don’t hesitate to get in touch!

Thanks for submitting!

© All rights reserved by Manifesto Rakyat 2022. 

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
bottom of page